Published Date: Feb 22, 2013
How justice works in Pakistan?s tribal areas and beyond
in Pakistan’s tribal border areas is a contested issue. "We are quite
clear what justice is. If someone kills, commits adultery or some other
offence, they deserve to die," said Javaid Khan of the Utman Khel tribe in
Bajaur Agency, one of seven tribal agencies (districts) along the
Pakistan-Afghanistan border, according to a report by Integrated Regional
Information Network (IRIN) of United Nations.
Talking from the town of Khar in Bajaur, he said "tribal justice" was
practised in the country, and killings had been carried out following verdicts
delivered by `jirgas’ (gatherings of unelected tribal elders)
saying: "We have our own means to keep order here. Yes, over the years,
killings have been carried out on `jirga’ orders – for murder, adultery or
Traditional justice is strong in many of these areas – but that comes at the
expense of universally accepted legal rights, say campaigners.
there is evidence that the will of powerful tribal elders holds sway over the
less influential," Asad Jamal, a Lahore-based lawyer, told. The less
influential, he said, "would include women".The `jirga’ courts are a community-based form of justice, deciding right and
wrong in areas where national official judicial structures are out of reach.
power is particularly strong in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA),
which are only covered by limited parts of the Pakistan Penal Code and the 1973
Instead, FATA operates under the Frontier Crimes Regulation (FCR) of 1901:
colonial-era laws that condone collective punishments and lack a right of
appeal or trial by jury.
are widespread, notably in tribal areas and affect women more adversely than
men by holding back progress for them, keeping them confined to within the four
walls of their houses, preventing them from acquiring education, and promoting
damaging traditions like child marriage," said Naveed Ahmed Shinwari,
chief executive officer of the Lahore-based Community Appraisal and Motivation
Those who campaign against the justice of `jirgas’, say they often deliver
injustice, in part because women have so little power over their decisions.
women are not represented on the `jirgas’, verdicts often go against
them," Samar Minallah Khan, a human rights activist and documentary
film-maker who has worked extensively in Khyber Pakhtoonkhwa Province (KP),
told from Islamabad.
The hold of tradition and "traditional justice" extends beyond the
more legally autonomous tribal belts.
said women in KP were "frequently produced before jirgas", most often
in cases of `swara’ or "marriages of exchange", where they were
handed over to an aggrieved party to settle a dispute, including murder or
other crime. "Under-age girls are often produced before jirgas by their
fathers in such cases," Minallah said.
The `jirgas’ often help reinforce discrimination against women, which can be
particularly acute in rural areas in the north.
national law applies, three men were shot dead in January this year as a result
of a long-standing tribal feud involving allegations their brothers had mingled
with unrelated women.
"In Kohistan, the ease with which people are willing to kill women, often
on `jirga’ orders, is shocking. It is just something completely acceptable to
them," said Farzana Bari, chairperson of the Women’s Study Centre at
Quaid-e-Azam University in Islamabad and a well-known women’s rights activist
who headed a Supreme Court inquiry into the case.
our culture men and women unrelated to each other are not permitted to mingle
at all," Nazir Kohistani, a businessman who now lives in Peshawar but has
origins in Besham, Kohistan, told. He said he had moved to Peshawar when his
three daughters were infants "so they could be educated and lead a normal
Women’s rights curtailed
Maryum Bibi, head of the Peshawar-based NGO
Khwendo Kor (Sisters’ Home, in Pashto), which promotes the education and
empowerment of women, told IRIN: "Such traditions, and the power of
`jirgas’ hold back women – preventing even their education, as well as other rights."
A survey by the Islamabad-based NGO Sustainable Policy Development Institute
(SDPI) conducted in six KP districts and Punjab Province, the results of which
were released to the media last month, found a large proportion of men in both
provinces believed that there were situations in which it was necessary to use
physical violence against women, and that banning violence was a "Western
Nevertheless, SDPI’s monitoring and evaluation team said that traditional
`jirga’ courts still had a degree of popularity in the surveyed areas."It is difficult to change established ways," said Shandana Bibi* who
now lives in Peshawar, but hails from Mohmand Agency. "We as women can
only try, but despite my efforts I have been unable to persuade my husband to
allow our two daughters to study beyond grade five."She says she will need to "fight hard" to allow her daughters to
receive even vocational training in sewing or embroidery, and the right to
leave their home to receive the training.Businessman Kohistani says he has come up against the same issues. He told:
"In areas such as ours, there are women who never, ever leave the four
walls of their home, simply moving from the home of their parents to that of
their husbands. I did not want my daughters, or my two sons, to grow up in such
a culture, and therefore I escaped it."However, escape is not possible for most. Nor do they necessarily wish to
abandon old ways.
live as are grandfathers and great grandfathers did, we keep to our own ways as
tribesmen; we believe life must follow tradition so we preserve our culture –
and we are proud of the morality that comes with this," said Javaid Khan
He says his main concern is to "keep change away since it will worsen, not
improve our lives, ruining morality, especially for women, who need to be
modest and kept away from public life."